Last week eBay released an ‘uninspiring’ set of figures – with growing pressure to offload StubHub and focus on ‘core’ business.
On Wednesday (23.10.19) eBay reported its Q3 2019 results, which revealed another uninspiring quarter of drift, with the marketplace apparently impacted by the growing number of US states imposing ‘Internet Sales Taxes’, but completed another $1.1Bn of share repurchase whilst paying out $115M in dividends.
This is a period of transition for eBay with interim CEO Scott Schenkel, confirming the portfolio review continues with a potential disposal of StubHub imminent (with – as we reported on Friday – an update to be announced before the next earnings release in January 2020), and the eBay Classifieds division review ongoing.
Big and flat
With regards to the quarterly performance of StubHub reported revenues were $306M up 5% Y-O-Y, but with GMV (Gross Merchandise Volume) of $1.23Bn flat in what is an expanding sector.
Flat implies StubHub is experiencing erosion of secondary ticketing marketshare to competitors, whether from primary platforms whom are increasingly offering dynamic pricing tools for tickets, the impact of digital ticketing enabling restrictions over ticket transferability, emerging companies with white-labelled ‘ethical’ ticket exchange or resale functionalities, or other PE-empowered secondary marketplaces.
Nevertheless given that eBay originally acquired StubHub for $310M in 2007 and – despite the current stand-still nature of the business – the scale is impressive with $4.7Bn annual GMV and $1.1Bn in revenues.
Pressure on sale
However, eBay has been under pressure for a number of months from various activist investors including ‘Elliot Management’ & ‘Starboard Value’ to sell off the ticket resale marketplace in order to maximise shareholder value.
Industry commentators have also opined that StubHub could operate more effectively within an ownership structure more aggressively targeting growth.
One observer, Gary Alexander, went so far as to describes latest set of figures as “eBay core business continues to rot” with consumer preference for Amazon-style shopping (as opposed to auction sites) and the growing impact of digital sales taxes impacting growth prospects. More on Alexander’s take on eBay’s “over-valuation” situation here.
StubHub itself claimed the ticketing sector was ‘soft’ due to fewer top tier artists active during the US summer season, but that this was offset by a ‘solid start’ to the NFL season and strong double-digit performance in its international markets. But as Scott Schenkel noted in the Earnings Call: ‘95% of the business, or more, is in the U.S.’.
On a brighter note, Schenkel applauded the efforts of Sukhinder Singh Cassidy (President StubHub) and her team to integrate digital ticketing where StubHub have direct relationships with (typically Sports) Rights Owners and to the overall seamless platform UI. He said: ‘It’s got an amazing seller base (with) tickets to almost every venue and every league for every game and every show in a way…. it’s got a good share. And it’s got a really nice user experience that we continue to evolve.’
But, ultimately StubHub will be sold-off – with potentially big ramifications for the global ticketing sector.
Other articles in our Finance Insights series:
- (7 June 2019): Riding the rollercoaster with Accesso
- (31 May 2019): Millennial Ticket Discovery – TodayTix vs GetYourGuide
- (15 May 2019): LiveNation Entertainment Q1/19 Analysis
- (26 April 2019): StubHub’s performance in the wider eBay picture
- (19 April 2019): DEAG – Growing & diversifying the portfolio
- (4 April 2019): Eventbrite’s stock performance since IPO
- (22 March 2019): CTS Eventim’s dividends and performance
*ABOUT THIS ANALYSIS: This series of financial insights is provided by the The FP&A Team at TheTicketingBusiness. The FP&A Team comprises a group of industry finance experts who volunteer their expertise to provide ad hoc analysis of key industry financial, M&A, funding and investment news. All in an effort to better-inform the market and support the industry’s long term development. Any questions or feedback welcome to firstname.lastname@example.org
Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only and may not be reproduced or distributed to other persons without written permission. This article is not a substitute for the necessary advice on the purchase or sale of securities, investments or other financial products. In respect of the sale or purchase of securities, investments or financial products, a banking advisor may provide individualised advice which might be suitable for investments and financial products. This article is based on generally available information and not on any confidential information. We (the author(s) and publisher) believe the information included herein to be reliable, but we do not make any warranties regarding its accuracy and completeness. This article constitutes the current judgment of the author(s) as of the date of publication and is subject to change without notice. It may be outdated by future developments, without this article being changed or amended. The authors receive no compensation or hold any financial interest in the company or companies featured. In short, all/any ‘FP&A at TBF’ Insights are personal opinion only and do not constitute investment advice. All commentary, and content is for informational purposes only. Do not construe any such information as official legal, tax, investment, or financial advice. For any investment decision you should always seek a professional financial advisor.