Judge did not quite reach the record-equalling 61st home run of the season, but tickets across various resale sites reached multiple thousands of dollars.
According to a report from the Daily Mail, tickets were listed for as much as $9,000 on Vivid Seats, and up to $1,000 on SeatGeek.
Tickets on Vivid Seats had tripled over the week leading up to the game, beginning at $115 and reaching as much as $330 by Sunday. Seats near the Yankees diamond ranged from $500 to $1,000.
StubHub was also promoting resale tickets for more than $2,000 as fans hoped that Judge would equal the record set by Roger Maris in 1961.
NBC New York also reported that tickets on Gametime, a mobile ticket marketplace app, had doubled leading up to Sunday.
The Yankees won after the rain cut the game at Yankee Stadium (pictured) short.